Home Research

Research noteMultifamily

The Apartment Supply Wave Is Past Its Peak. Your Rent Line Still Has to Earn Its Number.

New apartment completions have fallen about half from their 2024 high, and rent growth had cooled to under 3% as of September 2026. Here is what that means for the rent assumption in your underwrite.

J.C. Equity GroupFirst published in CRE Data on Substack

Most apartment underwrites live or die on one line: rent growth. Pick 5% a year and almost any deal pencils. Pick 1% and a lot of them don’t. So it is worth asking where that number should come from right now, and the public data has a clear story to tell.

What the data shows (through September 2026)

1. The building wave crested in 2024. Completions of new buildings with five or more units ran at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 705,000 units in August 2024. That was the fastest monthly pace since April 1974. By September 2026 the pace was 339,000, about 52% lower. August 2026 (295,000) was the slowest month since March 2022.

2. The yearly averages show the hump. Monthly completions averaged about 357,000 (annual rate) in 2022, 439,000 in 2023, 590,000 in 2024, 471,000 in 2025, and 408,000 so far in 2026 (January–September).

3. Rent growth has cooled a lot. The CPI rent of primary residence index was up 2.8% from September 2025 to September 2026. At its peak in March 2023, that same measure was up 8.8% year over year. Even cooled, rent is up about 33% since January 2020.

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau and HUD, New Privately-Owned Housing Units Completed: Units in Buildings with 5 Units or More (COMPU5MUSA, seasonally adjusted annual rate, thousands); U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U: Rent of Primary Residence in U.S. City Average (CUSR0000SEHA, seasonally adjusted). Both via FRED, retrieved 2026-11-10. Recent months can be revised. These are national statistics, not a forecast for any city, property, or loan.

Why it happened

Apartments take a long time to build. The projects that opened in 2024 were mostly planned and started when rents were jumping and money was cheap in 2021 and 2022. When rates rose and rent growth slowed, fewer new projects started, and that drop is what is showing up in completions now.

That lag works in both directions. A wave of new units arriving at once pushes landlords to offer concessions and hold rents to fill buildings. That is part of why rent growth slowed even while demand held up. Fewer new units arriving later can take some of that pressure off, but only in markets where the new supply actually slows.

What a sponsor can do with it

1. Underwrite rent growth from today, not from 2022. A national number near 3% is a sanity check, not a target. If your model assumes rent growth well above what the market is showing now, write down why your property is different.

2. Look at your submarket’s pipeline, not the national one. National completions falling by half does not mean your block is clear. Check local permits and projects under construction within a few miles of your property, and ask when they open relative to your lease-up or renewal schedule.

3. Price in concessions. If nearby new buildings are offering a free month, your “market rent” may really be about 8% lower on an effective basis for that year (one free month out of twelve). Underwrite effective rent, not asking rent.

4. Run the flat-rent test. Show the deal with zero rent growth for two years alongside your base case. If debt-service coverage (net operating income divided by debt payments) still holds, the plan is sturdy. If it breaks, you know which assumption you are depending on.

5. Match the exit to the timeline. If your plan depends on selling or refinancing in year two or three, the supply picture in that window matters more than today’s. Write a dated Plan B and the trigger that would make you use it.

A simple way to see it

Multifamily

Apartment completions, 5+ unit buildings

339K

September 2026, annual rate. About 52% below the August 2024 peak of 705K.

Apartment completions in buildings with 5 or more units, January 2019 to September 2026, seasonally adjusted annual rate: peak 705,000 in August 2024; 339,000 in September 2026, about 52% lower.0400K800K201920232026705K339K
Source: U.S. Census Bureau and HUD via FRED (COMPU5MUSA), seasonally adjusted annual rate, retrieved Nov 10, 2026. National data, not a forecast.
Rents

Rent growth, year over year

2.8%

September 2025 to September 2026. The peak was 8.8% in March 2023.

CPI rent of primary residence, percent change from a year earlier, January 2019 to September 2026: peak 8.8% in March 2023; 2.8% in September 2026. No October 2025 value.0%5%10%2019202320268.8%2.8%
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED (CUSR0000SEHA), seasonally adjusted, retrieved Nov 10, 2026. BLS did not publish an October 2025 value for this series because of the 2025 lapse in federal appropriations, so the line skips that month. National data, not a forecast.

National data · not a forecast for any market.

The takeaway

The supply wave is easing nationally, and rent growth has come back to earth. Neither fact sets your rent number. Your submarket, your concessions, and a flat-rent stress test do. Put those three beside your base case and the rent line earns its number.

If this was useful, subscribe to CRE Data for cited lessons like this.

Subscribe to CRE Data

James Witherington, Founder · Opinion and general teaching, not a forecast or advice.

J.C. Equity Group connects sponsors to financing options — we arrange, refer, and structure. Educational only. J.C. Equity Group is not a lender, and any terms come only from a lender, in writing. Business-purpose loans to business entities only. Not available in every state; we’ll tell you up front if we can’t work on your property’s state or your company’s state. Nothing here is an offer of securities or investment advice.

J.C. Equity Group does not offer or sell securities. Our lessons are educational and never include offering materials or invitations to invest.